Saturday, 17 January 2009

MCC To Follow The Law Concerning Property Tax

P.M.Bhat, Member, Mysore Grahakara Parishat writes


A delegation from Mysore Grahakara Parishat met MCC Commissioner K.S. Raykar recently and apprised him of violation of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations (KMC) Act in the implementation of SAS scheme for property tax by Mysore City Corporation. The delegation consisted of President Maj.Gen.(Rtd.) S.G. Vombatkere, Treasurer P.M. Bhat and S.A. Prasad. The Revenue Officer of MCC, Ms. D. Bharathi also attended the meeting. The Commissioner, who revealed that it was he (while posted in Bangalore) who drafted the relevant amendments to the KMC Act, agreed with MGP's contention and promised to instruct the concerned personnel at all MCC ward offices to follow the law strictly.

The MGP delegation pointed out the following violations of the law.

Despite the fact that Sec. 109A (amended in 2005) of the KMC Act clearly states that the same property tax collected in 2005-6 should be collected in 2006-7 and 2007-8, MCC collected enhanced property tax in 2007-8 based on guideline property values revised effective from 24-7-06. Property tax rates were also enhanced from 0.3% to 0.6% in 2007, again in contravention of Sec. 109A of the KMC Act.

According to this Sec. 109A, property tax stands enhanced by 15% for 2008-9 and this enhanced value will remain unchanged till 2011-12 when it will again be enhanced.

If MCC follows Sec. 109A strictly, one does not have to do any calculation at all on the tax form. The property owner can submit a copy of an earlier year's filled and paid tax form and that will fix how much he/she has to pay this year. No fresh calculations are necessary (unless the building is altered).

Sec. 109A gives power to the state government to introduce the 15% enhancement earlier than three years. But it can only advance the enhancement date. Using revised property values as the basis for tax calculation, as was done in 2007, is not permitted.

Sec. 109A also gives power to MCC to increase the enhancement rate (at the end of every three years) from 15% subject to a maximum of 30%. But it has to pass a resolution at the council meeting. MCC has no power to increase the tax rates. So the increase from 0.3% to 0.6% introduced from the beginning of 2007 is illegal.

Draft Amendment to Karnataka Electricity Regulatory (Fees) Regulations, 2004

A letter written by MGP president, Maj Gen S.G.Vombatkere (Retd) to the Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commission

Subject: Draft Amendment to Karnataka Electricity Regulatory (Fees) Regulations, 2004

Sirs,

1. If the work at KERC involved in processing Power Purchase Agreements is not commensurate with the fee charged, then the fee has to be increased. We have no objection to raising the fee from Rs.1,000/MW to Rs.5,000/MW for conventional fuel-based plants as proposed in the draft amendment.

2. However, we strongly urge that the fee for Power Purchase Agreements in respect of nonconventional and renewable sources of energy including cogeneration should not be raised from Rs. 500/MW to Rs. 5,000/MW as proposed in the draft amendment to the KER (Fees) Regulations. In the context of global warming and consequent climate change, it is accepted that carbon emissions are to be reduced. Since the electric power sector is responsible for nearly a quarter of all global carbon emissions, nonconventional and renewable sources of energy which do not contribute heavily to carbon emissions require to be encouraged very vigorously to reduce carbon emissions and hence reduce global warming. So we strongly recommend that the fee applicable to Power Purchase Agreements of nonconventional or renewable sources of energy including cogeneration be retained at Rs.500/MW to encourage investors in such generation stations.

Monday, 5 January 2009

Leaking Water Main


B.V. Shenoy, Member, Mysore Grahakara Parishat writes

The water main which takes water from the Yadavagiri High Level Reservoir to Bannimantap and surrounding areas is leaking badly at the intersection of Vivekananda Road and 3rd Cross, Yadavagiri.

The leak started more than two weeks ago and is getting worse every day. It poses a threat to public health since bacteria and other contaminants can get into drinking water during periods of negative pressure. Also the road is getting severely eroded from the leaking water.

Repeated complaints to MCC have not produced any results. We hope MCC wakes up soon and attends to this growing problem.

Kudos to MCC For Prompt Response


A few days ago, we had complained about the improper way manholes on roads are being repaired by Mysore City Corporation. We had given two examples (Vivekananda Road and Hunsur Road) in which the repaired manhole covers were about six inches above the road surface and hence posed a threat to traffic.

Within 48 hours after our complaint appeared in the media, Mr. Ananda Krishna, a junior engineer in the MCC Zone 4 Office came with a group of workers and got the manhole on Vivekananda Road redone so that its cover is flush with the road. He and his team are to be congratulated for responding quickly to a public safety problem.

It is hoped that they will be equally efficient in removing the debris from the repaired manhole soon so that they pose no hindrance to smooth flow of traffic.

Friday, 2 January 2009

Unprofessional Manhole Repair

Mysore City Corporation is on a manhole-repairing spree. Several damaged manholes all over the city are being repaired. MCC is to be commended for waking up to this serious problem.

Photos show the work in progress on Hunsur Road (in front of CIIL) and Vivekananda Road, Yadavagiri (near SBI).

But there are a couple of problems with the repair work. Firstly, it is taking too long. In both the examples above, work was started a month ago and is still not complete. Obstructing traffic flow and posing danger to vehicles for this length of time is not acceptable.

Secondly, the manhole covers were flush with the road surface before the repair was undertaken, but now they are about six inches above the road surface. Creation of ill-designed road humps by such unprofessional work will pose a danger to vehicles for a long long time. This problem should be rectified immediately.

Monday, 29 December 2008

Lots of money spent, but the purpose forgotten

B.Vaikunth Shenoy, Member, Mysore Grahakara Parishat writes

The storm water drains of Yadavagiri were repaired recently at enormous expense. Granite slabs were laid across the drains and grouted. There is no doubt it looks very nice.

But now the rain that falls on the road has no way of getting into the storm water drain. So it has to flow on the road itself. Also the level of the slabs covering the drain is higher than the road and so even the rain that falls on the slabs comes back on to the road. With so much water flowing on steep road, the road has been eroded badly and several potholes have formed. With the potholes and the gravel loosened by the flowing water, the road is quite dangerous to drive on. Heaven have mercy on the two-wheeler drivers negotiating this road.

To make the drains look nice, Mysore City Corporation has sacrificed the road. Bravo!

Thursday, 25 December 2008

Irregularities in Booth-Level Committees

G.L. Nagaraj Urs, Member, Mysore Grahakara Parishat writes

Booth-level Citizen Committees were established in Mysore some time ago to fulfill the requirements of JNNURM grants. The intention of these committees is to decentralize power and allow citizens of a particular local area to participate in the planning for that area, in accordance with the 74th Amendment to the Constitution. In the beginning, it was thought that this was the sole purpose of these committees and so only citizens genuinely interested in serving their communities applied for membership. Applicants with the best qualifications were supposed to be appointed, but this has not happened. With increasing awareness that the committees also wield significant financial power with each committee getting Rs. 10 lakhs, vested interests have stepped into the picture and appointments to these committees have become irregular, with rules, regulations and fair play thrown to the winds. I give here one example of booth No. 122 for which I obtained information from the Assistant Commissioner of Mysore City Corporation zonal office in Krishnamurthypuram. There were only three lady applicants for the booth-level committee, but two were rejected leaving only one. But two ladies have been appointed to the committee. How was the second appointment made when she had not even applied? On what grounds were two applications rejected? Of the seven appointees to the committee, only four names appear in the voters list of booth no. 122. The other three are from booth nos. 117, 140 and 148. Why were these outsiders appointed to the committee of booth no. 122?

There is no end to such puzzling questions. Similar grave irregularities must be occurring in other booth-level committees also. Unless these appointments are made totally transparent so that only concerned and competent citizens are appointed, the committees will only squander their budget with no benefit to the general public The very purpose of the 74th Amendment will be then defeated

Wednesday, 24 December 2008

Misleading information regarding JNNURM in the article on Star Of Mysore

Star of Mysore, in an article titled "Centre Says 'No' To Outer Ring Road Under JNNURM" reports that the project was planned to be taken up under JNNURM at a cost of Rs. 90.70 crores and a proposal to this effect was sent to the Centre for approval. The Centre has written a letter to resubmit the proposal with clarifications on some technical points and with regard to acquisition of land.

Syed Tanveeruddin, member, Mysore Grahakara Parishat writes,

Many of the statements in the article run contary to the statements of the Government. In response to my aaplication under Right to Information Act, Mr. Rajesh Jaiswal, Under Secretary (NURM-II) of the Ministry of Urban Development of the Government of India replied on 18-11-08 on the status of the JNNURM projects in Mysore. A scanned image of his letter is enclosed as five Attachments.

According to the letter of the Under Secretary, the estimated cost of the Outer Ring Road Project as submitted originally was Rs. 90.70 crores. But the cost approved by the Ministry of Urban Development was Rs. 219.02 Crores, i.e., more than double the original proposal. The letter also says that Rs. 43.80 Crores HAVE BEEN ALREADY RELEASED.

Since Rs. 43.80 Crores have been already released for the project by 18-11-08 (the date of the MoUD letter), the statement that the Centre has said no to the project can not be correct.

The article in SOM states "The Centre in its letter dated Sept. 29 has informed that it is not possible to place the proposal before the CSMC as it is not of prominence under the National Urban Transport." This can not be true since according to the letter of MoUD, not only has the project been approved, more money than asked for has been approved and 25% of the approved money has already been released.

The article in SOM also states that KUIDFC has written a letter on 22-11-08 to the Centre and the DC has written on 10-12-08 to reconsider the proposal. This is strange since the money has already been released.